This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Special Holiday Hours: Our store will be open on Monday 12/23! Visit Us.

Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $300 away from free shipping.
No more products available for purchase

Products
Pair with
Add order notes
Estimate shipping
Subtotal Free
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa

10 Tips on How to Buy a Diamond Engagement Ring

Are you ready to pop the question? First, you'll need the perfect diamond engagement ring. Whatever your style, the search should be pure joy, not overwhelm. Finding the right engagement rings comes down to knowing your fiancée's tastes and telling your unique love story while staying within your budget. Follow these ten must-know tips from Valerie Madison to find the ring of their dreams.

Know Your Budget

Setting a practical budget should be the first step when buying a diamond engagement ring. Knowing how much you’re willing to spend will help narrow down your options and keep the search enjoyable. There are several ways to approach setting a budget:

  • Some people allocate a percentage of their annual income toward the purchase, while others prefer a more flexible approach. Spread the cost over time with flexible payment plans to ease your wallet’s worries.
  • If you’re mindful of the diamond's characteristics, you don’t have to compromise on quality. For example, choosing a slightly lower color or clarity grade can reduce the cost while still appearing flawless to the naked eye.
  • If diamond size matters most, you can focus on getting a larger carat weight while choosing a lower clarity grade. On the other hand, if brilliance is the priority, investing in a well-cut stone might mean opting for a smaller diamond within your budget.
  • Set a realistic budget and prioritize your must-haves. You’ll find an engagement ring that checks all the right boxes — style, sparkle, and affordability. Buying something special doesn't have to mean sacrificing your savings. Valerie Madison offers flexible payment options to help you stay within budget.

Learn the 4Cs of Diamond Engagement Rings

When shopping for a diamond, you must understand the 4Cs: Cut, Color, Clarity, and Carat Weight. A diamond's value is sealed when these four specific traits come together in harmony. Here’s what each letter means and why they matter.

Cut

The cut is perhaps the most crucial factor influencing a diamond's brilliance. A diamond's fire is all about the way its faceted surfaces bounce light around. A round brilliant diamond, for instance, is cut for maximum sparkle due to its many facets, making it the most popular diamond shape.

Color

Diamonds are graded on a scale from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow or brown). Did you know diamonds have color? Some do, but the less color a diamond has, the higher its value. While colorless diamonds are rare and expensive, diamonds in the G-J color range offer great value and appear nearly colorless.

Clarity

Clarity is what determines the presence of internal flaws (inclusions) or surface defects (blemishes). Most inclusions are microscopic and don’t affect the diamond’s beauty. Higher clarity grades, however, are recommended for step-cut diamonds like emerald cuts, which show imperfections more easily.

Carat Weight

Carat refers to the weight of the diamond, with larger carat diamonds being rarer and more valuable. But remember, bigger doesn’t always mean better. A smaller-carat diamond with a higher-quality cut can look more brilliant than a larger diamond with poor cut quality.

Seeing things through the 4Cs lens helps you pinpoint your top priorities, separate the important from the irrelevant, and make choices that align with your objectives.

Feeling the pinch between designing something amazing and staying within your means? Don't go it alone. Seek some expert advice. Valerie Madison's experts can assist with creative solutions that match your taste and budget constraints.

Pick the Right Metal

Whether your fiancée prefers a radiant glow or a sleek shine, the type of metal you select will dramatically impact the appearance and durability of your engagement ring. Jewelry makers might offer a roster of metals, including platinum, white or yellow gold, and under-the-radar choices like titanium and palladium, each contributing a distinct personality.

At Valerie Madison, 14-carat yellow gold takes center stage in their stunning engagement ring collection. Golden treasures don't have to be fragile; this alloy-rich metal puts toughness alongside glamour, so your ring stays stunning no matter the task. It's a premium choice for an engagement ring that's fashionable and built to last.

Choose the Right Diamond Ring Setting Style

The setting style you choose secures the diamond and influences the ring's overall look and feel. From safeguarding to style, the options available in different settings offer a balancing act between function and fashion. Some engagement ring settings are more popular than others, such as these frequent bestsellers.

  • Prong Setting: The most classic choice, the prong setting uses metal claws to hold the diamond in place. The number of prongs can vary, with six prongs offering more security for the diamond and four prongs providing a more open look.
  • Bezel Setting: This setting encircles the diamond with a thin metal rim, offering excellent protection. For active folks, this choice is a no-brainer. The diamond stays put, and your wardrobe staples remain snag-free. Bezel settings work well with step-cut diamonds, such as emerald cuts, where a secure setting is crucial.
  • Halo Setting: When a circle of smaller diamonds surrounds the center diamond, it’s called a halo. This setting makes the diamond appear larger and adds extra sparkle. Elevate your jewelry game with this chic setting, expertly designed to bring out the best in a range of diamond shapes.
  • Solitaire Setting: A solitaire engagement ring features a single diamond as the focal point, making it a choice that never goes out of style. The sleek lines of a diamond cut straight to the point, showcasing its sheer brilliance. The result is simply radiant, paired with a timeless round brilliant or oval shape.

Whether you're looking for an engagement ring that's elegant, adventurous, or simply classic, the right setting style can make it all come together.

Choose a Diamond Shape

Diamond shapes can impact the overall appearance of your ring. While round brilliant diamonds are the most popular shape due to their sparkle, other shapes like oval, marquise, and emerald cuts offer unique looks. A diamond's fancy shape says a lot about the person who wears it. A delicate heart tells a romantic story, while a bold triangle exudes confidence. Below are 6 engagement ring diamond shapes to know as you shop for this all important piece of jewelry.

  • Round Brilliant: The classic choice for those seeking the most sparkle. Its 58 facets are designed to reflect light from all angles.
  • Oval: Similar to the round brilliant in sparkle but with an elongated shape that makes the wearer's finger look longer.
  • Emerald Cut: Known for its clean lines and "hall of mirrors" effect, this shape exudes elegance and sophistication.
  • Marquise: This shape offers a distinctive look with its elongated body and pointed ends, often making the diamond appear larger than its carat weight would suggest.
  • Pear and Heart Shapes: For a touch of uniqueness, these fancy shapes add character to the ring.

Before making a decision, slow down and appreciate the unique characteristics of each diamond shape. You might be surprised by which one calls your partner's name. When it comes to choosing a ring, the shape is more than just a detail; it sets the tone for the entire piece.

Look at Diamonds Under Different Lighting

Diamonds can be tricky to gauge, as their appearance changes under different lighting conditions. Make sure to inspect your potential purchase in many lights to get an accurate read on its brilliance. Diamonds can light up like fireflies under intense spotlights, broadcasting their brilliance to anyone nearby. You can't really get a sense of a diamond's character until you've seen it in a range of lighting conditions.

Try on the diamond in different settings. You'll quickly see if it's a keeper. For example, round brilliant diamonds may look dazzling under bright lights. Still, observing their sparkle in more common environments, such as dim or office-style lighting, is equally important.

Seek Expert Guidance and Opinions

Engagement ring shopping can be complex, with so many details to consider, from diamond quality and metal types to ring settings and trends. Look to the experts for guidance. It's often the smartest move you can make. With their help, you'll get customized advice that steers you straight. They can also help you with figuring out the wearer's ring size.

There's more to a quality ring than meets the eye. The trifecta of diamond grading reports, setting security, and ethical sourcing can transform your ring from nice to nailed it. Understanding the terminology can be overwhelming. But with an expert by your side, you'll get expert advice on finding the best piece that reflects your style, fits your budget, and makes you feel confident.

What to Ask the Experts

When consulting with a jeweler, come prepared with questions. Diamond shapes aren't created equal. Some rocks sparkle like crazy, while others could be total bombs regarding durability. Get the lowdown on which shapes deliver. Inquire about the pros and cons of various ring settings, like prong versus bezel.

Get Opinions from Loved Ones

Aside from local jewelers, it’s wise to chat with friends or family who have recently gone through the whole process. Take a page from their playbook. Their stories can help you dodge mistakes and skip the learning curve. Ask what they loved about their choice and what they might do differently.

Leverage Online Resources

Seek guidance from those closest to you, then fact-check with reputable websites. You can search websites like the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) or the American Gem Society (AGS). They provide helpful guides on diamond grading and quality standards.

At Valerie Madison, we help people like you discover or craft unique diamond engagement rings that reflect their love story. We'll decode the technical jargon and work hand-in-hand with you to craft a custom ring that embodies your personality, all while finding the perfect setting to complement your active lifestyle.

With insight from local jewelers or friends and family who've gone through the process, you'll walk out of the jewelry store with a ring that screams, "This is the one!"

Choose Ethically Sourced Natural Diamonds

When buying an engagement ring, it’s essential to consider where the diamond comes from. At Valerie Madison, we understand the significance of ethical sourcing and work exclusively with natural, brilliant, earth-mined diamonds.

Behind every diamond, there's a story of responsibility. Ours are certified through the Kimberley Process, which verifies that our diamonds are free from any link to violence or conflict. For us, it's about sharing diamonds with a narrative that checks out. With a stickler's eye for detail, we verify the origin of every diamond so you can trust it's impeccable.

By choosing Valerie Madison, you can be confident that your diamond engagement ring is beautiful, ethically sourced, and responsibly acquired. From respected suppliers around the globe, we hand-select the most exquisite natural diamonds to bring our clients only the best.

Keep Up with the Trends

While traditional engagement ring styles will always have a place, staying informed about the latest trends can help you find a ring that feels current and exciting. Trends such as vintage-inspired, feminine rings, stacked wedding bands, and gemstone engagement rings are gaining popularity.

Diamond enthusiasts love oval cuts, a chic modern twist on the traditional round. Hidden halos slyly inject a dose of sophisticated glamour for added subtlety.

However, don't get swayed by what's hot right now. While trends are great, what’s more important is your fiancée. Pick a style that speaks to you and your partner on a deeper level. That way, you'll avoid dated looks and opt for something that will remain stunning for a long time.

Plan Ahead for Custom Rings

Planning ahead is essential if you’re considering designing custom engagement rings. Custom rings take more time to produce, so allow enough time for the design, adjustments, and final production.

The process will start with an initial consultation. This meeting is when you’ll discuss your vision. Afterward, a CAD rendering is created, allowing you to see the design before it’s made. Once the design is approved, production begins.

Before you start designing, make sure everyone's speaking the same language. Lay out your expectations and throw in some inspiring designs for good measure. The finished ring will be exactly what you had in mind, with every detail accounted for.

Planning ahead and maintaining clear communication with your jeweler will ensure your custom engagement ring turns out perfectly.

Consider Ring Maintenance

Both women’s and men’s engagement rings require ongoing maintenance to retain their sparkle and durability. Different metals and settings have specific care requirements. Routine cleaning can be done using a soft-bristle brush, mild soap, and warm water to gently clean your ring. For more thorough cleanings, schedule a professional cleaning every six months.

It is essential to always check for loose stones. These settings may require more frequent inspections to ensure the small stones remain secure. Proper care will ensure that your engagement ring stays as beautiful as the day you bought it.

Understand Engagement Ring Insurance

Your engagement ring is a significant investment, so it’s essential to insure it. Jewelry insurance typically covers loss, theft, and damage, offering peace of mind.

Start by getting an appraisal from a certified jeweler. You can add the ring as a rider to your homeowner’s or renter’s insurance policy or purchase a separate jewelry insurance policy.

Insurance policies usually cover theft, accidental damage, and even loss. Be sure to review your policy carefully to understand the specifics. Having insurance on your engagement ring ensures that your investment is protected, no matter what happens.

Only Buy From Trusted Jewelers

Buying from a reputable jeweler is crucial to ensuring you get a high-quality, ethically sourced diamond. The risks of buying from untrustworthy sources include misrepresented diamond quality, poor craftsmanship, and even conflict diamonds.

Always ask for a diamond grading report from a reputable laboratory such as the AGS or GIA. These certifications verify the diamond’s quality and authenticity. Read reviews, ask for references, and ensure the jeweler offers warranties and return policies before making your purchase.

Valerie Madison’s reputation is built on trust, high standards, and ethical sourcing. We ensure that each diamond we sell is conflict-free and sourced through the Kimberley Process.

Let Valerie Madison Help You Shine

Choosing your significant other’s diamond engagement ring is a special journey. It’s about more than just finding a beautiful center stone; it’s about finding a piece of jewelry that symbolizes your commitment and love.

Picture this: both of you walk into a room, and everyone's eyes land on your fiancée’s ring. The oohs and aahs make your fiancée smile even bigger. That's what Valerie Madison's collection promises. These breathtaking designs combine classic elegance with modern panache, guaranteeing you'll make an unforgettable impression.

Take the first step in crafting the ring of their dreams. Collaborate with our experts to design that exquisite and enduring ring. The right engagement ring is a story waiting to be told. Our team of experts will help you write that story to create an unforgettable ring.