This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Seattle's Only Black-Latina Owned Fine Jewelry Store

Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $300 away from free shipping.
No more products available for purchase

Products
Pair with
Add order notes
Estimate shipping
Subtotal Free
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa

How to Buy an Engagement Ring: The Ultimate Guide

Choosing an engagement ring is a big decision filled with excitement, emotion, and, sometimes, a little bit of pressure. This daily reminder of your love will sit proudly on their finger, a tangible representation of the vows you've made, so you want to get it right!

With so many options available, knowing where to start can feel overwhelming. Should you go with yellow gold or white gold? A traditional solitaire or something more modern, like a halo setting? And, of course, how do you find the perfect ring within your budget?

Picking out an engagement ring can be overwhelming, but don't worry — Valerie Madison has you covered! From understanding what makes a diamond sparkle to selecting the metal and setting that fits your style, we'll guide you through every step.

Ready to seal the deal with the ultimate love token? Let us help you give a gift that wraps up all your feelings into one beautiful package. Our guide is here to help you do just that, with expert tips on choosing a truly meaningful keepsake.

What Does an Engagement Ring Symbolize?

Think of an engagement ring as a contract of the heart — a beautiful, wearable promise that this person is your rock, your confidant, and your forever partner.
Slipping that ring onto your partner's finger is a statement of forever — a bold declaration of love and loyalty. Centuries of romance have passed since that iconic symbol of commitment first appeared on fingers, marking the beginning of a lifelong bond between two love-struck people.

Traditionally, the circle of the ring signifies eternity, with no beginning and no end. Strong and luminous, the chosen stone, often a diamond, embodies the same unwavering spirit that fuels a lifelong connection.

Choosing an engagement ring is an emotional decision. You want a keepsake that embodies the whispers, laughter, and inside jokes that make your bond unique — something that says “I get you” and “I love you” all at once. Whether you opt for diamond engagement rings, gemstones, or designing custom engagement rings with personal touches, each ring tells its own story.

Shopping for an engagement ring morphs into a thoughtful, deliberate process for these very reasons. You're about to choose a daily partner that'll stick with you through thick and thin and ultimately become a family heirloom.

The Difference Between an Engagement Ring and a Wedding Ring

While engagement rings and wedding rings are often used interchangeably, they serve distinct purposes. An engagement ring is given during the proposal, a promise to marry, and usually features a prominent center stone. It’s often designed to stand out and is worn from the moment of the proposal onward.


Wedding rings are exchanged during the wedding ceremony itself. These bands are usually simpler in design. Many prefer wedding bands with fewer details, like a simple metal band or one with small accent stones that complement the engagement ring. While both rings are worn together, the engagement ring tends to be the more elaborate piece, while the wedding band adds a layer of significance to the marital commitment.

Consider Matching Wedding Bands with Engagement Rings

Once you've chosen the perfect engagement ring, the next step is often finding a wedding band that complements it. Some people prefer matching bands, while others may opt for a contrasting style. Finding a wedding band that aligns with the engagement ring's style and practical aspects is key. For instance, a classic solitaire engagement ring may look stunning paired with a simple metal band, while a more ornate setting might match well with a diamond-studded wedding band.

It’s also essential to consider the shape of the engagement ring’s setting. Some wedding bands are contoured to fit snugly against specific ring settings, especially for larger center stones or unique shapes. Some wedding bands even have an open center for the engagement ring to slide in and couple together.

Understanding The 4Cs of Diamond Engagement Rings

After reading our 5 stones to avoid in an engagement ring, let’s say you’ve decided on diamond engagement rings. Before you head to the jewelry store, you must first understand that the 4Cs of diamonds — cut, color, clarity, and carat weight — are vital for a diamond ring. Look closely, and you'll find that many critical factors converge to shape the quality, firepower, and price tag of every diamond. We're about to crack open the process of what you need to know.

Diamond Cut

The cut of a diamond is often considered the most critical factor in determining its sparkle. The cut refers to how well the diamond’s facets interact with light, affecting its brilliance. A well-cut diamond reflects light beautifully, giving it that signature sparkle.

Diamonds with poor cuts don’t reflect light as effectively, making them appear dull. Whether you choose a round, marquise, or emerald cut, a high-quality cut ensures your diamond shines.

Diamond Colors

Diamonds range from entirely colorless to shades of yellow or brown. The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) grades diamonds from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow or brown).

A colorless diamond is rarer and thus more valuable, while diamonds with more color are more common and less expensive. Many jewelers recommend diamonds in the G to J range for a good balance of quality and value, as these stones appear nearly colorless to the naked eye.

Diamond Clarity

Clarity refers to internal or external imperfections, known as inclusions and blemishes. While flawless diamonds are the rarest and most expensive, most diamonds contain minor imperfections invisible without magnification.
The GIA grades diamonds for clarity on a scale from Flawless (no inclusions) to Included (inclusions visible to the naked eye). For most buyers, a diamond with slight inclusions that aren’t noticeable without magnification will offer the best value.

Diamond Carat Weight

When discussing diamonds and gold, you might encounter two spellings: "karat" and "carat." While they sound similar, they refer to different things. "Carat" is used to measure the weight of diamonds and other gemstones, whereas "karat" is used to describe the purity of gold. Carat weight plays a significant role in determining the size and value of diamonds.

The carat weight measures the size of the diamond. Larger diamonds are rarer and, therefore, more expensive. However, carat weight alone doesn’t determine a diamond’s beauty.

A well-cut diamond with a smaller carat weight can appear more brilliant than a poorly cut diamond with a higher weight. When buying an engagement ring, consider your partner’s preferences for size while balancing other factors like cut and clarity to find the perfect diamond. Focusing only on carat weight might lead to sacrificing other essential qualities that enhance the overall look of the diamond.

Types of Engagement Ring Metals

Choosing the right metal for your engagement ring is as important as selecting the stone. Depending on the metal, a ring can be either a fashion statement or a long-term investment, with some metals offering style and substance in equal measure.

Classic Metals

Classic metals like yellow gold, white gold, and platinum are timeless and have been used in women’s and men’s engagement rings for generations. From the wallet to the maintenance schedule, these metals vary in ways that go beyond their appearance. It's these practical differences that can make all the difference. When it's time to choose, gold and platinum stand out as ultimate rivals. The gold shines with its cheerful charm, while platinum dazzles with icy allure, both vying for top spot in the beauty-and-strength show.

Yellow Gold

Yellow gold is one of the most traditional choices for engagement rings. A subtle, warm beauty radiates from this hue, capable of bringing out the best in various skin tones. One of the major benefits of yellow gold is its resilience - it can handle the rough and tumble of everyday life without losing its charm.

White Gold

White gold offers a sleek, modern look. What happens when you blend pure gold with nickel and a few other alloys? A bright silver-toned look that is elegant and looks great on a variety of skin tones. White gold is a versatile and affordable alternative to platinum.

Rose Gold

Rose gold has recently gained popularity for its romantic, warm pink hue. By merging gold with copper, a warm, eye-grabbing color emerges, giving this metal an identification all its own, separate from the sterility of gold or platinum. Breaking free from the conventional, rose gold engagement rings take you back to when romance was tender and true, with a subtle nod to the here and now.

Platinum

Platinum is the most durable and hypoallergenic metal available for engagement rings. Its naturally white sheen won’t tarnish over time. Though platinum scratches and develops a matte finish with wear, this adds to its character without diminishing its strength. Platinum's uniquely sturdy constitution and alluring aesthetic explain why it's the prime pick for rings built to last—destined to shine through countless days, moments, and memories.

You've got the love — now it's time to get the ring right. That starts with choosing a metal that's just as special. Metals put on a personality show, each with its own blend of style, staying power, and "you-ness." Whether you choose classic yellow gold or a modern alternative like, finding a suitable metal ensures your ring is stunning and long-lasting.

How to Buy an Engagement Ring

Treating the engagement ring purchase as a puzzle to be solved makes it feel less intimidating and more exciting. Engagement ring shopping can feel like a wild goose chase, but fear not! Our expert advice will steer you toward the perfect symbol of your love.

Determine Your Budget

The first step in buying an engagement ring is setting a budget. Quality doesn't have to break the bank; lab-grown diamonds and flexible payment plans make it possible to stay within budget without sacrificing style. What’s most important to your partner — a big diamond, a unique setting, or a custom ring design? Plan your budget based on this information.

Select a Center Diamond or Gemstone

The center stone is the focal point of any engagement ring. While diamonds are the most traditional choice, many couples opt for gemstone engagement rings that add a pop of color and personality. Sapphire engagement rings, for example, offer a vibrant alternative to diamonds, while lab-grown diamonds provide an ethical and budget-friendly option without sacrificing brilliance. Consider your partner’s personal style when choosing between diamonds, gemstones, or a combination of both.

Pick Your Ring Style and Setting

The style and setting of an engagement ring are key to creating a piece that truly reflects your partner’s personality. From the overall look to how the center stone is showcased, every detail matters.


What kind of ring will your partner adore? Think about their job, hobbies, and fashion sense to make the right choice. Do they lead an active life and need a durable, low-profile ring, or are they drawn to bold, intricate designs?


The setting you choose affects the ring’s appearance and the security of the center stone. Pick a style and setting that harmoniously blends form and function to make your ring a faithful everyday companion.

Ring Styles

Engagement rings come in a wide range of styles, from classic solitaires to intricate vintage designs. Think about your partner’s style preferences — do they prefer something timeless, like a simple solitaire, or something more elaborate, like a halo setting? Understanding your partner’s style will help guide your decision.

Metal Type

Choosing the proper metal is crucial to finding a ring that reflects your partner’s personality. With metals ranging from sleek and modern to vintage-inspired, think about what style your partner rocks on a daily basis and choose a metal that complements it.

Ring Size

Getting the ring size wrong is a common pitfall that can ruin the experience. If you’re unsure of your partner’s ring size, try borrowing one of their existing rings for a close measurement. If that’s not possible, enlist the help of friends or family members. And if all else fails, go slightly larger — it’s easier to resize a ring down than up.

Taking time to choose the perfect ring style and setting ensures that your engagement ring will not only look stunning but also reflect the unique bond you share with your partner. Crafting a ring that'll be loved for years means considering the little things that make your special someone who they are — their passions, personality, and even the ring's fit on their finger.

Choose a Reputable Jeweler

Finding the perfect jeweler is how your engagement ring will make it through the harsh daily wear and tear. Using a professional jeweler who consistently produces high-quality pieces, is truthful about their methods, and treats customers like gold is crucial.

Get the scoop from people who've been there. Read reviews, grill your friends and family for their honest take, and don’t skip over the warranty and guarantee details. A jeweler that stands by its product is always a good sign.

With exceptional craftsmanship at its core, Valerie Madison prioritizes the environment by sourcing high-quality materials responsibly, yielding eye-catching fine jewelry treasures. With a solid reputation in the jewelry industry, they're the preferred partner for anyone looking to create a genuinely personal engagement ring that turns heads. With Valerie Madison, you’re investing in fine jewelry crafted with care and built to last.

Complete Your Purchasing Process

Your ring search has ended, and now it's time to take the final leap: completion of the purchase. Many jewelers, including Valerie Madison, offer financing options to help you manage the cost of the engagement ring. Don’t forget to ask about warranties and engagement ring insurance to protect your investment. Once the paperwork is complete, you’ll be ready to propose with confidence.

Find the Ideal Engagement Ring at Valerie Madison

The clock is ticking, and anticipation is building! The hunt for that extraordinary ring begins — a thrill that'll stay with you both for a lifetime. With so many details to consider, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. This guide should help decrease that stress!

You'll create a symbolic masterpiece that speaks volumes about your relationship. From the first step to the final fit, our team at Valerie Madison is committed to guiding you in finding or designing the ring of your dreams. Shop today and craft a piece that speaks to your forever promise — a symbol your partner will hold close to their heart for years.